Some years ago as I was working on on a historical novel – I think it was Bucker Dudley – I realized suddenly that I was too deep into the thing. I truly felt that if I didn't get every single detail right not only would it throw the reader out of the story, it would throw me out of the story, like stepping on a crack and breaking your mother's back. That moment in Somewhere in Time comes to mind, when Christopher Reeves pulls the modern dime out of his his historically correct vest pocket and throws himself back into the late twentieth century, leaving behind the woman he loves.
It wasn't even the fear of suffering public shame. (That's when you get fifty or sixty letters from readers pointing out how you messed up, along with several snarky Amazon reviews.) It was this conviction I had that my portrayal of the environment of a story had to be so perfect that anyone who happened to be transported to that time and place could use it for a map.
Sick, right? First of all none of us are ever going back there. There's no such thing as a time machine. Secondly, the environment of a story exists in the service of the story, and not the other way around. All that's required is that the historical details be plausible. What, after all, is Truth?
It was Harold who reminded me of the convention of Poetic License. So I whipped up an authentic Poetic License and posted it over my desk.
Now I am able to invent bogus historical details without fear or shame. When at a gathering of historians no less an authority than Professor Paul Israel, the world's foremost Edison scholar, gently pointed out to me that there was no such thing as the portable film strip hole punch I had described in The Edge of Ruin, I was able to smile. Because the hole punch served the story.
Kate Gallison
Blog Archive
-
▼
2012
(58)
-
▼
December
(12)
- Larry Light - Triple Crowner: Financial Genius, To...
- The 2012 Retrospective
- Christmas in the Village Redux
- Inside Santa Claus
- Crime Family Values
- Book Covers: What Sells Books?
- The San Joaquin Valley's Special Crime Writer – Su...
- Kate's Cherry Chocolate Chocolate Chip Cookies
- Not How I Imagined It
- Jack Partridge: Why Pool?
- Poetic License
- Hank Phillipi Ryan, Crime Writer Par Excellence
-
▼
December
(12)
Popular Posts
-
We need to talk. Before my thoughts on this subject solidify. On Facebook, two or three of my friends tend to post or share pictures eight...
-
I was a New York City policeman for 20 years: from 1967 to 1987, seminal years in the modern history of the NYPD, during which I rose from P...
-
Some people come into this world nicely dominant in their left brains and therefore neurologically prepared to spell well and find typos at ...
-
The greatest joy, for me, of being an active member of MWA/NY is the people I meet. Jerry is one of them. He is one of our few dramatists....
-
Words are unnecessary to tell the glory of Rome. The pictures below will give you a tiny taste. But I will tell you a story at the end--a...
-
No, even though it is almost December and trees are lit up all over Manhattan, this post is not about a little girl and a Santa-impersonator...
-
I met Stephen Solomita at an MWA dinner 20-plus years ago. I struck up a conversation, having read his first novel, A Twist of the Knife , w...
-
As you know, I have been cleaning my attic for some weeks now, in the attempt to put it in shape as a comfortable guest room for company we&...
-
Somewhere in my wanderings through the internet last week I came upon a book recommendation that I was moved to follow up on. The book was T...
-
Day after tomorrow our votes will decide the direction of our beloved land for decades to come. Maybe a whole century! Not the opposing side...